Google Reviews: Why They Matter for US Restaurants’ E‑Reputation
Online reviews have a massive influence on where people choose to eat. In fact, 94% of U.S. diners base their dining decisions on online reviews , and 88% of Americans trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations . This means a restaurant’s star rating and review count can make or break its ability to attract customers. Diners often check ratings even before viewing the menu or visiting the venue, treating reviews as a proxy for word-of-mouth reputation.
Crucially, a strong rating isn’t just vanity – it impacts the bottom line. Studies show that 87% of consumers won’t even consider a business with an average rating below 3 stars . In other words, falling into the low-3-star range (or worse) can deter nearly nine out of ten potential guests. On the flip side, higher ratings are linked to more revenue. For example, a Harvard study found that a one-star rating increase led to a 5–9% boost in revenue for independent restaurants . The takeaway: maintaining a great online reputation isn’t optional – it’s essential for success in the restaurant industry.
When it comes to restaurant reviews, Google is the dominant platform in the US by far. Roughly twice as many people check Google reviews compared to the next leading review site . To put this in perspective, 48% of consumers surveyed used Facebook for reviews in 2024, and 44% used Yelp, making those the next most popular platforms – but Google eclipses both . TripAdvisor, once a major player, has seen declining usage in recent years (only 21% of consumers used TripAdvisor in 2024, down from 36% in 2022) . Especially for everyday dining and local searches (as opposed to tourism), Google is the go-to source for restaurant information.
Google’s edge isn’t just in user preference – it also hosts the vast majority of review content. By one analysis, Google houses about 73% of all online reviews, which is more than six times as many reviews as the next sites (combined) . In comparison, other review sites like Yelp, Facebook, and TripAdvisor each hold only single-digit percentages of total reviews . This dominance is reinforced by Google’s integration into daily habits: when someone “googles” a restaurant or looks it up on Google Maps, the Google Business Profile with its star rating and reviews is front and center, influencing the decision on the spot . In short, Google reviews are indispensable – they are the most visible and frequently consulted review source for restaurants, far outpacing Yelp, TripAdvisor, or others in the U.S. market .
Real Example: Boosting Google Reviews with sunday’s QR Code
One way restaurants have capitalized on the importance of Google reviews is by using technology to make it easier for guests to leave feedback. A notable example is sunday, the QR-code payment solution. According to Sunday, restaurants that use their digital bill system experience 5× more 5-star Google reviews on average . Every time a guest pays via the Sunday app, they’re seamlessly prompted to leave a Google review – converting happy diners into online advocates with minimal friction.
For instance, Hole in the Wall, a full-service restaurant group in New York City, has seen a dramatic impact on its online reputation since adopting sunday. Today, 82% of their positive Google reviews are driven directly by sunday’s QR code payment flow. The seamless review prompt integrated into the payment experience has significantly boosted their visibility and customer acquisition.
“The review prompt feature improved our online presence and SEO, leading to more revenue.”
— Tom, Manager, Hole in the Wall
The impact extends beyond reviews. When Parched Hospitality Group (owner of Hole in the Wall) rolled out sunday across 10 of its venues over three months, they observed a consistent and measurable uplift:
“When we rolled out sunday in 10 of our restaurants over 3 months, top-line revenue went up 10% every time. We are very happy with the platform and the amazing service from the team.”
— David Orr, President & Owner, Parched Hospitality
This case clearly shows how streamlining the review process at the moment of payment not only increases review volume and quality, but also contributes directly to business growth. By eliminating friction, sunday turns satisfied guests into vocal advocates with a single scan—boosting both SEO and sales.
(In general, technology like Sunday’s platform shows that if you make the review process quick and convenient, many more happy guests will actually follow through and share their experience .)
Best Practices for Managing Your Restaurant’s E‑Reputation
To stay on top of your online reputation, consider these best practices (with an eye toward full-service and chain restaurants in the US):
✅ Claim & Optimise Your Google Profile
Make sure your Google Business Profile is claimed and fully filled out — hours, photos, menu, reservation link, etc.
Google pulls these directly into Maps and Search — so this profile is your homepage for many diners.
Use high-quality photos, update your menu frequently, and encourage customers to add photos in their reviews.
✅ Encourage Reviews (the Right Way)
The best time to ask for a review is immediately after a great experience. sunday makes this frictionless at the end of the meal.
Add QR codes on table talkers or the receipt (non-intrusive but visible). sunday’s approach of prompting every paying guest with a Google review link is a great illustration of this principle.
Never offer discounts in exchange for reviews — it violates Google’s policy and can lead to review suppression.
✅ Monitor Reviews Daily
Use the Google Business app or tools like Feed It Back or sunday’s built-in dashboard to track feedback in real-time.
Set up alerts for new reviews. Fast response (especially to bad ones) shows you care and protects your rating.
✅ Respond to Every Review — Yes, Every One
96% of consumers read business responses, so replying isn’t optional — it’s public brand-building.
Thank positive reviewers. For negative reviews, stay calm, empathetic, and offer to resolve privately.
Even a 3-star review can become a loyalist if they feel heard.
✅ Learn and Adapt
Use aggregated feedback to train your team, adjust your offer, or revise your service flow.
For example: if multiple diners mention long waits for drinks, investigate bar service speed or shift timings.
Consistently acting on reviews shows diners you care — and improves the experience over time.
Conclusion
In summary, Google reviews are a cornerstone of restaurant success in 2025. Nearly everyone checks them, Google dominates the review landscape, and a high star-rating with recent positive feedback can directly translate into more customers and revenue. Restaurants that thrive are those that actively engage with this reality – by delivering great experiences, encouraging satisfied patrons to leave reviews, and diligently managing their e-reputation across platforms. As we’ve seen, leveraging modern tools (like Sunday’s QR-code payment + review system) can amplify these efforts, yielding remarkable gains in review volume and quality . Whether you run a single location bistro or a nationwide chain, staying on top of online reviews is key to staying competitive.
Find out more today
Drop us your details below and we’ll reach out within the next 24h
4min
4min
