1min
Running a successful restaurant depends on more than just a good location and a tasty menu. According to the National Restaurant Association, restaurants with consistently lower turnover and higher employee satisfaction rates often attribute their success to strong managerial practices. Staff management isn’t just about scheduling and delegating tasks—it’s about setting the right tone, nurturing a positive culture, and ensuring each team member feels motivated and respected.
Yet even experienced restaurant managers can fall into common pitfalls that undermine morale, invite conflict, or drive valuable team members away. Below, we’ll examine some of the most frequent errors in managing restaurant staff and explore how to steer clear of them. By recognizing and addressing these missteps, you can foster a more engaged, loyal workforce—and, ultimately, a thriving dining experience for your guests.
One of the top errors managers make is assuming everyone automatically knows what’s expected or happening. In a high-paced environment like a restaurant, assumptions can lead to costly mistakes and misunderstandings.
Signs of the Problem: Staff repeatedly asking the same questions about daily specials or shift changes. Orders getting mixed up because the kitchen crew didn’t receive timely notes on modifications. Servers missing out on updates, like a dish that’s suddenly unavailable.
What to Do Instead: Offer concise pre-shift briefings that clarify new menu items, any promotions, or expected guest volume. Encourage questions and ensure staff have channels—like group messaging or a staff board—to stay informed about changes throughout service. Frequent, two-way communication helps your team feel more confident and reduces avoidable hiccups.
In the rush to fill positions, some managers skip or shorten training periods. They might assume new hires will “learn on the go” or simply copy experienced coworkers. But this approach can backfire, leading to uneven service quality and quick burnout.
Signs of the Problem: Inconsistent knowledge among servers—one might know the menu thoroughly, while another seems clueless. Frequent mistakes, like undercharging on the POS or forgetting crucial health and safety procedures. Frustrated senior staff who must constantly correct new teammates.
What to Do Instead: Invest in a structured onboarding process—covering brand values, menu details, POS training, and best practices for service and safety. Pair newcomers with a seasoned mentor for a few shifts. Ensure all staff get refreshers when you add new dishes or adopt new technology. Thorough training fosters confidence and consistency, which benefits both staff retention and guest experience.
Some managers worry that, without close supervision, staff will slack off or make errors. But over-monitoring every move can undermine trust, stifle creativity, and create a toxic atmosphere.
Signs of the Problem: Employees seem anxious, always double-checking trivial tasks to avoid criticism. Staff rarely propose new ideas or solutions, fearing their suggestions won’t be taken seriously or will be overly scrutinized. Morale is low, and turnover rates spike.
What to Do Instead: Provide clear guidelines and training, then allow staff to implement them in their own style. Check in periodically—particularly for newer hires—but focus on feedback and guidance rather than constant oversight. Encourage team members to take initiative, like creating special cocktails or improving workflows, and recognize them when they succeed.
Restaurant work can be physically demanding and highly stressful. Managers who ignore signs of burnout or assume staff can handle perpetual late nights and double shifts risk driving good employees to seek relief elsewhere.
Signs of the Problem: Persistent fatigue or lower-quality output from once-enthusiastic team members. High absenteeism or last-minute sick calls. Tension, conflicts, or apathy taking hold during busy stretches.
What to Do Instead: Aim for schedules that give employees fair rotation of peak and slower shifts. Try to limit back-to-back late night and early morning (a.k.a. “clopening”) shifts. Ensure breaks are actually enforced, and encourage staff to voice concerns about workload. If you show genuine care for their well-being, staff are more likely to stay and perform better.
Not all workplace disputes simply dissolve if ignored. Similarly, not all staff problems—like tardiness or sub-par performance—vanish without addressing them. Managers who hope issues will “sort themselves out” often see those problems grow worse.
Signs of the Problem: A small rift between two cooks escalates into open hostility. Guests complain about inconsistent service, but managers sidestep direct confrontation with the underperforming server. Staff remain stuck in misunderstandings because no one steps in to clarify roles.
What to Do Instead: Approach conflicts swiftly and privately, facilitating clear, constructive conversations. Offer specific, balanced feedback—acknowledging the employee’s strengths while highlighting areas for improvement. A manager who addresses problems early fosters a culture of transparency and keeps teamwork cohesive.
Everybody likes being appreciated. Yet some managers assume a paycheck alone keeps staff content. In an industry known for tough conditions and long hours, a lack of recognition can sap motivation and lead employees to question their value.
Signs of the Problem: Good employees losing enthusiasm, no longer suggesting ideas or going the extra mile. A rise in resignations from staff who once excelled. Minimal sense of camaraderie or pride among servers and cooks.
What to Do Instead: Congratulate an entire shift for a record-breaking sales day, or highlight the bartender who invented a popular new drink. Remember birthdays or job anniversaries. Even small gestures—like a “Thank you for tackling that large party so well!”—build staff morale. Publicly celebrating achievements encourages a sense of belonging and commitment.
It’s normal to have trusted veterans you rely on, but showing blatant preferential treatment or failing to apply rules consistently spells trouble. When staff sense unfairness, resentment can quickly undermine unity.
Signs of the Problem: Complaints that certain servers get prime shifts or easier sections, while others are stuck with less desirable roles. Rules (like dress code or punctuality) enforced for some but overlooked for others. Staff gossip or negative chatter about management’s bias.
What to Do Instead: Outline policies—on lateness, shift assignments, tipping structures—in writing, and stick to them. If you do grant exceptions (like swapping a shift for personal reasons), clarify the reasons so others see it’s a fair, situational decision. Offer opportunities to all who demonstrate readiness, not just a select few. Consistency fosters respect and trust.
An “every man for himself” mentality might get the job done, but it rarely generates a memorable dining experience or a cohesive workforce. Staff who only see their coworkers as competition for tips or recognition seldom develop unity—and customers often sense the lack of synergy.
Signs of the Problem: Little collaboration between front-of-house and back-of-house, leading to slow service or occasional blame games. Lack of willingness among servers to help each other when one is slammed. No communal camaraderie—everyone just clocks in and clocks out.
What to Do Instead: Encourage collaborative problem-solving, from daily huddles to cross-training or group brainstorming sessions. Organize occasional team-building events, like a simple after-service snack or a quick local volunteering initiative. Openly praise examples of staff assisting each other. This unified approach elevates the overall environment and service quality.
Finally, some managers push aggressive sales goals—like upselling expensive dishes or urging servers to close out tables faster for higher turnover—without balancing the need for genuine hospitality. This short-sighted strategy might yield minor immediate gains but erode customer satisfaction and staff morale over time.
Signs of the Problem: Guest complaints of feeling rushed or “nickeled and dimed,” employees chafing at unrealistic quotas, and a transactional vibe overshadowing the warm, inviting ambiance.
What to Do Instead: Clarify that yes, you want strong revenue, but not at the expense of authentic hospitality. Teach “soft selling” or gentle menu recommendations that truly enhance the meal. Recognize big wins (like when a table orders multiple courses) but also celebrate consistent, positive guest feedback. Balancing sales goals with quality service fosters lasting patron relationships and stable staff retention.
Managing a restaurant team is no small task, given the pressures of fast-paced shifts, high customer expectations, and razor-thin profit margins. But falling into common errors—like unclear communication, unequal treatment, or neglecting recognition—can quickly unravel staff morale and customer satisfaction.
The good news? By staying mindful of these pitfalls, focusing on empathy, clarity, fairness, and teamwork, you can build a culture where employees feel respected and empowered. In such an environment, consistent excellence thrives: your staff gain the confidence to deliver top-notch service every day, and your guests sense the harmony behind the scenes, returning for more. Ultimately, effective management is about forging the human connections that keep your restaurant’s heart beating strong.
Drop us your details below and we’ll reach out within the next 24h
sunday elevates your business with insightful data, instant feedback and precise analytics.
