0min
One of the most straightforward explanations for January’s tipping adjustment is simpler than any fancy recipe: People tend to have less disposable income right after the holidays. Gift shopping, traveling to see family, or hosting large dinner parties leaves many diners feeling financially stretched. And since eating out is often viewed as a treat, the added expense of a tip can become a point of cost-cutting.
Here’s how it typically unfolds:
For restaurants, this is a double whammy: traffic might dip as temperatures drop and people stay indoors, while tips also slide downward. Although these circumstances can be sobering, recognizing them is the first step to effectively tackling the issue.
The calendar flip from December to January might seem like merely turning a page, but in reality, it’s a complete shift in consumer mindset. The holiday season is packed with merriment—plenty of family-style meals, festive outings with friends, and a widespread inclination to spread “holiday cheer.” After all, no one wants to appear stingy when it’s supposed to be the most generous time of the year.
Then January arrives, bearing messages of self-improvement, financial discipline, and careful spending. People focus on budgets and try to avoid “wasteful” expenses. Tipping can end up in the crosshairs, especially with obligatory monthly bills—rent, health insurance, student loans—looming large. This pivot might not necessarily be a conscious choice to tip less, but rather a by-product of an overall effort to reign in expenses.
For servers, bartenders, and baristas who rely on tips as a significant portion of their income, this psychological shift can feel unsettling. They’re the frontline personnel experiencing lower gratuities, and if unprepared, they can become discouraged just when you want a fully engaged team to deliver great service. This is where restaurant leadership plays an essential role.
While seasonal affective disorder (SAD) typically describes a pattern of depressive symptoms triggered by changing seasons, we can borrow the term loosely to hint at an emotional undercurrent in guest behavior during the winter. Shorter days and chilly weather can dampen spirits or prompt diners to stay home. Those who do dine out might not linger as long or spend as freely on extras like a dessert or a second bottle of wine.
All these emotional and physiological factors can lower the average check size. A smaller bill, of course, often translates to a lower tip total. In addition, guests feeling moody might be less patient with service, which can affect the percentage they leave behind. A diner who previously tipped 20% might drop to 15% if they perceive service to be slower or if they’re simply in a less supportive mindset.
Now that we’ve set the table with reasons why tips shrink in January, let’s explore how you can respond. Below are specific tactics that can soften the impact and support your hardworking staff:
Team cohesion and morale are priorities. Letting your staff know in advance that January can be tougher encourages everyone to prepare. Some restaurants share historical sales and tipping data from previous years to paint an accurate picture. By doing so, servers won’t feel blindsided, and they can plan personal finances accordingly.
To combat the typical slow down, you can design enticing winter offerings. Think of it as your secret “January Warm-Up Menu”—a comforting soup and sandwich combo at lunch, or a limited-edition spiced hot cocoa in the evenings. Consider promotions that encourage customers to spend a bit more, like pairing deals (entrée plus dessert) or small freebies that prompt diners to feel thanked and valued. The sense of value these create can translate into more satisfied customers who tip generously.
No matter the time of year, smooth payment experiences can nudge customers to tip. Using digital options—like scanning a QR code at the table to pay—often includes suggested tip percentages right on the screen. This extra nudge can lift the average gratuity by making it crystal clear how much a 15%, 18%, or 20% tip equates to in dollars, and it also simplifies the moment of payment.
With sunday, for instance, customers can pay quickly from their phone. They see a tip suggestion in a friendly, transparent manner—no pressure, but a gentle cue that a gratuity is a standard part of dining. They can also leave feedback on their experience or even link directly to write a review on Google, reinforcing loyalty and motivating your staff.
When budgets tighten, service must sparkle. Train your servers to offer a cozy, upbeat dining experience—be that friendly voice that brightens a chilly January afternoon. Sometimes, just a warm smile and a few words of empathy can help diners decide to be generous with their tip. Empower your team to greet customers quickly, check in at the right moments, and adapt to each table’s vibe.
Some simple ways to elevate hospitality:
These details may seem small, but in January, small details can lead to big kidness that resonates with patrons.
Some restaurants partner with local movie theaters, boutique shops, or winter festivals during the slow months. Offering a collaborative promotion—like “Show Your Ticket Stub and Get 10% Off an Appetizer”—can drive traffic. With more diners, your servers get more opportunities to earn tips. Encourage guests to pay by scanning a modern payment system at the table; a small convenience can lead to a big difference in gratuities.
Hard data can provide clarity and help you make strategic decisions. In addition to seasonal reference points, keep an eye on your own restaurant’s data. Measures you might track include:
Consider using your restaurant’s point-of-sale system or integrated software tools to analyze these trends. Reviewing last January’s data is an excellent start, but keep it ongoing: measuring real-time metrics can help you adjust on the fly. If you notice that lunch crowds are nearly nonexistent in midweek, for instance, you might close earlier or switch to a takeout-friendly menu midday to preserve labor costs and keep your best staff on the busiest shifts.
Historical data from the National Restaurant Association also indicates that US restaurant sales can dip a bit early in the year as consumers shy away from eating out. This trend is by no means universal, but it’s common enough to treat it as an important reference point.
Winter storms or extremely low temperatures can keep diners indoors, especially on weeknights. On the flip side, if there’s a popular local event—like a basketball game or a winter festival—restaurants close to the venue might see a boost in traffic. Monitoring the weather forecast and local event schedules becomes more important in January:
Sometimes, the best approach involves a combination of strategic staff scheduling, targeted promotions, and flexible payment solutions that adapt to the challenges January weather can present.
Anyone who’s worked in a kitchen or on the dining floor knows that tips significantly impact team morale. When January’s lower tip volume starts affecting staff’s monthly income, negative feelings can arise—especially among front-of-house employees. Here’s how you can help moderate any negativity:
A cheerful, supportive environment, even when the tills aren’t overflowing, is exactly what fosters employee loyalty. And a happy staff means happier guests, which can help sustain tip amounts even in the gloom of January.
January might feel challenging, but it’s not without its silver linings. People who dine out this time of year may be looking for comforting experiences, making them receptive to personal touches. Some even have gift cards—perhaps received over the holidays—that they’re itching to spend. Taking advantage of these opportunities can lead to new regulars and brand loyalty.
Here are some positive angles to explore:
Such efforts can brighten an otherwise quiet month for diners and staff alike. The key is to think creatively and remember that each table in January is an opportunity to win loyalty, positive reviews, and yes, better tips.
Some restaurants, particularly in large urban markets, have adopted service charges or automated gratuities, especially for larger parties. While it may stabilize staff earnings, automated gratuities can also undermine the spirit of tipping—some patrons feel it’s mandatory and impersonal.
In January, it can be tempting to implement an across-the-board service charge to ensure your staff gets fair compensation despite a drop in tipping. Before moving forward, consider the following:
If you do opt for an added service charge in January, consider explaining that it helps maintain fair wages during the off-peak season. Transparency can help guests understand your rationale and feel more comfortable with the charge.
Restaurants dependent on tipping can also explore adjusting base wages for server roles, especially if you expect lower tipping in January. Although it involves higher labor costs, seeing staff well-compensated can reduce high turnover, which can be a hidden expense all year long. If you choose this route, weigh pros and cons carefully:
Balancing these factors is crucial, and each restaurant finds its unique approach. Some owners freeze hiring in Q1 and temporarily consolidate roles to reduce labor costs, ensuring that the staff still working have more tables and better tip opportunities. Others prefer stable rosters, emphasizing top-notch service even when business is slow.
A large part of your brand’s image revolves around the customer experience from start to finish. One surprisingly powerful way to encourage tipping is a modern, user-friendly payment system:
Payment technology seamlessly aligns with your pursuit of a better tipping environment. Instead of handing a customer a paper check, you can let them pay on their phone and easily see how a tip benefits the staff who worked hard to make their experience memorable.
No matter how cozy and inviting your restaurant is, you can’t change the fact that January arrives after the holiday rush. But you can manage how your restaurant responds to financial constraints, emotional mindsets, and tricky weather. Keep your eyes on data, craft winter promotions, and support staff with transparent communication. Emphasize a friendly, uplifting atmosphere that coaxes guests out of their post-holiday shells.
Above all, recognize that January’s shift in tipping patterns is both natural and temporary. By proactively planning, leaning into smart payment solutions (like scanning a QR code table-side), and encouraging your staff to deliver memorable hospitality, you can soften the seasonal impact—and maybe even turn it into an opportunity to stand out in your local community.
Below are some of the most common questions restaurant owners ask about the seasonal drop in tips and how to deal with it effectively.
A: Many diners feel the pinch of post-holiday bills and new year budgeting. This mindset often leads to smaller tips, even from regular patrons. January’s slower restaurant traffic and chilly weather can also intensify the effect on gratuities.
A: Emphasize open communication, so employees understand the seasonal dip isn’t their fault. Consider team incentives or cross-training sessions to keep morale high. Remind your staff that outstanding service still plays the most significant role in earning tips.
A: Absolutely. Customers who pay via smartphone or tablet often see preset tip recommendations, which can increase the average tip percentage. Fast, seamless payment also leaves a positive final impression, which encourages tugging at the heartstrings—and the wallet.
A: There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Mandatory service fees can stabilize staff income but might irritate freedom-loving patrons. If you do go that route, be transparent and communicative to prevent misunderstandings.
A: While careful scheduling can cut unnecessary labor costs, cutting staff too aggressively could harm service quality. Strive for a balance: ensure tables are well-served and employees remain motivated, but avoid having too many idle hands on the floor.
