1min
Picture a bustling dining room full of smiling people who can’t wait to come back. That’s the dream scenario every restaurant owner aims for. But how do you keep those guests returning regularly—not just on special occasions? One of the simplest ways is by using a well-designed loyalty program. It gives your diners a concrete reason to swing by again, whether it’s to earn points, redeem a free appetizer, or enjoy an exclusive perk.
According to Epsilon’s “Power of Me” research (A Brand New Take on Personalization), roughly 80% of consumers are more likely to make a purchase when businesses offer personalized experiences. Loyalty programs are a perfect avenue for that personalization—tailoring rewards to guests based on how often they visit or what dishes they love the most. And the payoff can be huge: higher average check sizes, more frequent visits, and stronger word of mouth.
The loyalty market offers countless solutions for restaurant owners. Each approach has its own flavor. But you’ll notice a few essential ingredients typically define whether a program will succeed or flop. As you evaluate any loyalty platform—whether it’s a simple punch-card concept or a fully digital app—keep these elements in mind:
It’s all about frictionless experiences. You want guests to feel their loyalty is recognized and rewarded instantly, without burdensome steps. And you want your staff to champion the program because it’s simple to explain and easy to manage.
Today’s restaurant industry is spoilt for choice. Broadly speaking, loyalty solutions fall into four main categories. Each has its pros and cons. Identifying which category fits your business model is the first step toward picking the right solution.
Let’s start old school. The punch card is an enduring classic—one of those “Buy 9 coffees, get the 10th free” deals. It’s simple and often cheap to implement. However, the pitfalls are equally clear:
If you run a small, cozy cafe where you know most diners by name, you might still find success with a physical card system. For the rest of us, going digital opens up more opportunities to track and engage customers effectively.
Some point-of-sale providers offer their own loyalty add-ons. This can be appealing if you crave an all-in-one setup that automatically tracks sales, compiles guest info, and runs basic loyalty campaigns. You’ll see benefits like:
On the flip side, you might end up paying extra for these integrations, and you’re limited to what that POS company chooses to develop or support. If you’re seeking advanced personalization—like segmentation, specialized promotions, or direct integration with new tech—some POS-based solutions might not keep pace.
A range of standalone loyalty platforms cater specifically to restaurants. Many are app-based, requiring customers to download something onto their phone. Others operate via SMS or email-based membership systems. Key benefits often include:
However, standalone systems sometimes require extra steps for both staff and customers. If your guest needs to whip out an app, scan a code in the app, then show it to the server, you risk friction. And your staff might need to manage one more platform in an already hectic environment. Balancing features with simplicity is crucial here.
A newer and increasingly popular category involves integrating loyalty features directly into the payment experience. The logic is straightforward: the moment your guest is paying is a prime opportunity to engage them. If you link loyalty to that payment step, sign-up rates skyrocket.
That’s where sunday comes in. The platform’s QR code checkout process allows guests to pay in seconds, leave a tip, and even post a Google review without jumping through hoops. If you connect your loyalty program to that same flow, enrollment or point tracking becomes a seamless part of paying the bill. By removing extra steps, you encourage more sign-ups.
The result is a frictionless experience that pleases both your customers—who don’t want an extra card or complicated app—and your team, who save precious time at closing out checks. This model also ensures you capture meaningful guest data, fueling your ability to customize future rewards.
While each solution category differs, they often share some overlapping features. Think of them like “universal add-ons” you can get, no matter the platform. Here are some you might want to prioritize:
As more restaurant owners embrace contactless and digital payment options, connecting that technology to loyalty programs becomes an obvious next step. sunday offers a prime example of a payment-integrated approach. When diners pay using sunday’s QR code, they have:
Many restaurants find that sign-up rates jump once there’s a fluid process at checkout. After all, diners are already using their phones to scan and pay—why not reward them for it, too?
Before choosing a loyalty platform, you need to understand which approach aligns with your goals and limitations. Let’s do a quick side-by-side glance:
Whichever platform you lean toward, there are a few universal considerations to keep top of mind.
Make sure your chosen loyalty solution plays nicely with your existing tools—like your reservation system, online ordering portal, or POS. If it’s a standalone app, will your staff have to type in every order, or can the system handle data automatically? If you opt for a payment-integrated approach, confirm that your current POS is set up to handle external payment flows.
The best loyalty program can fail if your servers don’t explain it well. Train them thoroughly. Provide short, scripted pitches: “Hey, we have a new loyalty reward if you pay via the QR code on your table—would you like to join?” Encourage them to mention it naturally during the meal or at checkout.
Costs vary widely. A punch card might just require printing expenses, while a high-end digital platform may bill you monthly fees and usage charges. Payment-integrated solutions, like sunday, often base their pricing on transaction volume or a subscription model. Regardless of the cost structure, weigh the potential ROI. Are you attracting more repeat business, boosting average checks, or gathering better data for marketing? Those gains can quickly offset the program’s expenses.
Data is the hidden gem that elevates a loyalty program from a mere punch card to a powerful strategy. Once you know who your regulars are, how often they visit, and which dishes make them happiest, you can tailor perks that feel truly personal. This fosters stronger connections—guests aren’t just collecting points; they’re feeling recognized and valued.
With robust loyalty insights, you can:
The more you use these findings in your daily decisions, the more effective your loyalty program becomes—an endless cycle of customer delight and increased revenue.
A big part of any loyalty solution’s success boils down to what you’re actually offering. A lukewarm reward might not excite your diners enough to return. On the other hand, you don’t want to lose money by giving away the farm. So how do you strike the right balance?
The best reward is one that feels thoughtful. If your diner adores your house-made desserts, a small sweet on the house can go a long way. If they’re a cocktail connoisseur, perhaps a free tasting flight. Know your audience, and your loyalty program will sparkle.
Even as we compare current solutions, it’s worth noting that loyalty programs are evolving quickly. Contactless payment is here to stay, and personalization will only grow in importance. Platforms like sunday position restaurants to harness these trends by integrating payments and customer engagement into one fluid process.
Imagine a future where, right after scanning a QR code to pay, your loyal guests get a personal thank-you message with next-visit suggestions tailored to their tastes—maybe a discounted new entrée or a reminder about your weekend brunch if they typically visit during weekdays. That level of thoughtful interaction turns a simple checkout moment into an ongoing conversation, one that customers appreciate for its relevance and ease.
At the end of the day, a loyalty program is about building real connections. It’s not just a marketing trick; it’s a commitment to saying, “We value you” to the people who keep your doors open. The right platform—whether that’s a time-tested punch card or a cutting-edge payment integration—should reflect your restaurant’s unique identity.
Are you a neighborhood bakery that wants to keep it old school and charming with paper punch cards? Or maybe a trendy eatery that thrives on contactless convenience, where sunday can integrate loyalty right into your digital receipts? Evaluate your brand, your customer base, and your tech capacity. Then pick the loyalty route that helps you form deeper bonds with your guests while keeping your team’s workflow smooth.
Once your loyalty program is up and running, monitor the results. Look at sign-up rates, redemption patterns, and overall satisfaction. Adjust your offers, communicate new rewards, and watch how a well-crafted program can transform casual diners into faithful fans. That’s the power of loyalty done right—turning each meal into an experience worth returning for, time and again.
Drop us your details below and we’ll reach out within the next 24h
See 62% of your customers join your loyalty program by integrating sunday.
