1min
Loyalty programs can make your restaurant feel like a warm, bustling dining room filled with familiar faces. By rewarding your regulars for visiting often or spending a certain amount, you show how much you value them. As a result, they come back more frequently, increase their average check size, and bring new customers through word-of-mouth. In fact, data from the National Restaurant Association (Restaurant Industry Facts) highlights how repeat business is the backbone of steady revenue. Establishing a loyalty program is an effective way to foster that consistency.
But here’s the catch: not all loyalty programs succeed. You might have the best fries in town or the friendliest staff, yet a poorly executed program can drive away guests rather than draw them in. Below are five common mistakes you need to avoid if you want your new loyalty program to be smooth, profitable, and truly loved by customers.
Think of your loyalty program as a well-seasoned dish—it should have just the right blend of ingredients without being overwhelming. When the structure is too complex, your guests won’t bother trying to figure it out. They’re there to enjoy your food, not solve a puzzle.
A points system that requires mental math—like earning 2.73 points for each dollar spent and needing 187 points for a free entrée—will cause confusion. A common question arises: “How close am I to my reward?” If your guests can’t answer that in a heartbeat, it’s time to simplify.
Tiers can be great—Gold, Silver, Bronze—but only if people immediately understand how to advance. If your customers are left asking, “When do I reach Gold? And what’s the real difference between these levels?” they might lose interest.
Remember, clarity trumps complexity. Guests should feel excited by the program and know exactly what they’re getting for their loyalty, not be bogged down in the details.
We live in an era of smartphone convenience, where paying by scanning a QR code or placing an online order can be done in seconds. Why not meet your guests where they already are? Traditional punch cards or manual sign-up sheets often get misplaced, and they rarely provide you with valuable guest data. This old-school method is also time-consuming for your staff—they have to explain or stamp cards each visit.
By switching to a digital platform, you make it seamless for diners to sign up, track their points, and redeem rewards. You also reduce friction for your staff, freeing them to do what they do best: creating a memorable dining experience.
One direct path to going digital is integrating loyalty sign-ups with payment. If you use Sunday’s QR code payment solution, for example, guests can pay, leave a tip, and receive a prompt to join your loyalty program in one smooth flow. The system can automatically update point balances and even encourage customers to leave a Google review. This user-friendly approach can significantly boost loyalty enrollments.
Once diners join your loyalty program, they expect real-time updates. No one wants to wait three days to see if their free appetizer has finally kicked in. By adopting a digital method, you can automate:
It’s like having a virtual host who never sleeps, always ready to welcome them back. That’s the kind of convenience modern diners appreciate, and it helps your business stand out in a competitive marketplace.
You could be handing out the world’s best saffron-infused soufflé, but if your guests don’t care for soufflé—or saffron—you’re missing the mark. Your loyalty program must offer rewards that genuinely excite your target audience.
Have you ever run a campaign for half-off wine bottles only to discover that many of your regulars prefer craft beer? It’s not about giving the largest discount, but giving a relevant incentive. When you tailor your rewards to guest preferences, they’ll feel that you “get them,” and that’s a powerful motivator for loyalty.
Sometimes, a meaningful perk doesn’t even have to be edible. Consider:
These gestures can create a deeper emotional bond. Diners feel like they’re part of an inner circle. When you show recognition that goes beyond free fries, you capture an intangible but potent form of loyalty.
A loyalty program is only as good as the people who promote it. Even the best-designed programs can flop if your servers, hosts, and managers aren’t fully on board or lack the knowledge to speak passionately about it.
Your staff should be able to explain:
If servers are unsure about these details, confusion spreads to your customers. The result: fewer sign-ups and wasted potential. Training sessions don’t have to be elaborate—brief, clear guidance can suffice. Then, reinforce that guidance during pre-shift meetings or in daily bulletins.
Ever had a server mumble, “We have a loyalty program if you’re interested” as they drop the check? That low-energy pitch likely won’t inspire a single sign-up. Enthusiasm is contagious. If your team is excited about the rewards and can share their own experiences with the program, diners will feel that authenticity.
When your staff stands behind the program, it transforms the way guests perceive it—turning what could feel like a sales pitch into genuine hospitality.
A loyalty program is never a “set it and forget it” proposition. Preferences change, and your restaurant might pivot its menu focus or expand to new locations. A static program that ignores these shifts can quickly become stale, causing members to lose interest.
You wouldn’t cook a steak without checking its temperature, right? Running a loyalty program should be no different. Analyze your data:
Look for patterns and outliers. If sign-ups spike whenever you launch a new limited-time reward, that’s a clue to run more short-term promotions. If certain perks go untouched, swap them for something more appealing. Constantly refine the recipe until it tastes just right to your guests.
Silence is the fastest way to let a loyalty program fizzle out. Once customers join, keep them engaged by communicating:
Send quick emails or text blasts. Post on social media. Use in-store signage. Show your members that you’re excited to have them, and they’ll be excited to remain active participants.
One hidden barrier that causes loyalty programs to stumble is accessibility. You want everyone—regardless of dietary needs or language preferences—to feel comfortable joining and participating.
When guests see you’re actively making them feel welcome, they’ll develop an even stronger bond with your brand.
A restaurant’s loyalty program is like a signature dish. You want it to reflect who you are, keep customers coming back for more, and generate that “wow” factor they can’t stop talking about. Avoiding these five mistakes can help you craft a strategy that adds to your bottom line—rather than draining resources on perks nobody uses.
Moreover, today’s technology makes it easier than ever to streamline your loyalty program. Solutions like Sunday’s QR code payment flow allow you to integrate sign-ups and reward tracking right into the payment process. It’s a frictionless way to capture guest data and keep them engaged through personalized offers and tips.
Your staff should be your biggest advocates, thoroughly trained to present the program with enthusiasm. The rewards should excite diners, match their preferences, and be simple to understand. By analyzing your metrics and continually evolving your offers, you ensure the program remains fresh and effective.
Keep in mind that your guests have many dining choices. A loyalty program helps them choose you again and again. By steering clear of complexity, embracing digital convenience, offering relevant rewards, training your team, and keeping everything fresh, you can transform occasional visitors into loyal fans. Those fans, in turn, become informal ambassadors for your restaurant.
So, refine your approach, sidestep these pitfalls, and watch your loyalty program become a key ingredient in your recipe for success. After all, happy regulars, higher revenue, and a buzzy reputation are some of the sweetest rewards you can earn in the restaurant world.
Drop us your details below and we’ll reach out within the next 24h
See 62% of your customers join your loyalty program by integrating sunday.
