1min
Picture a bustling evening in your dining room: patrons chatting energetically, servers gliding between tables, and a lively kitchen orchestrating the flow of mouth-watering dishes. That lively atmosphere depends heavily on returning customers—those who feel connected to your menu, your staff, and your brand. A loyalty programme can reinforce this connection, boosting sales and turning casual diners into committed regulars.
But not every loyalty scheme is created equal. Some may seem enticing at first but fail to truly engage customers, drifting into obscurity after the initial sign-up. Others might be so complex that diners skip them altogether. Today, the challenge for UK restaurateurs is to create a programme that’s simple, rewarding, and relevant to a diner’s evolving needs. In fact, modern consumers expect tailored experiences, digital convenience, and a sense of genuine appreciation for their repeat business. And if they don’t find it at your establishment, they might look elsewhere.
Let’s explore how to elevate your loyalty strategy into a powerful tool that keeps your tables full—without bogging you or your staff down in unnecessary complexity.
Before making any changes, it’s crucial to identify what you hope to achieve. Are you looking to bring in more off-peak traffic, encourage repeat takeaway orders, or promote a newly designed cocktail menu? Each goal will influence the type of programme you create. For example, if you’re aiming to boost weekday footfall, your rewards might centre on Tuesday lunch deals or discounted Wednesday night specials. This specificity keeps your loyalty scheme focused and more likely to deliver tangible results.
According to Deloitte’s “Loyalty Redefined” report (source), 73% of consumers in the UK state that personalised offers significantly affect their purchasing decisions. This underscores the importance of matching your scheme’s objectives to customer preferences. When your goals align with what your patrons actually crave, your loyalty programme can become a real differentiator in a crowded marketplace.
In an age where speed, convenience, and personalisation are king, diners want more than just the typical “buy five, get one free” card. They’re accustomed to digital solutions that let them see their points, rewards, or special perks at a glance—often via their smartphones. Many also expect immediate access to new offers, along with a quick and painless sign-up process. A cluttered or frustrating system can turn diners off faster than a cold plate of soup.
One example: a well-thought-out digital platform can prompt guests to join your loyalty programme right at the moment they settle the bill. If they simply scan a QR code to pay, they could be nudged to enrol in your scheme—no fiddly forms or separate apps required. Sunday, for instance, integrates these touchpoints seamlessly, so diners don’t have to jump through hoops. By meeting your guests’ demand for convenience, you set the stage for building a genuine connection, rather than a fleeting transactional relationship.
Getting the rewards just right is like seasoning a dish to perfection. Too little, and diners won’t bother returning for more. Too much, and you risk serving up profit-eating freebies. So how do you strike the perfect balance?
These strategies can revitalise a lacklustre loyalty programme. The key is to know your customers well enough to tailor rewards they truly value. If your best-selling dish is a succulent roast chicken, tying a special offer to that item can nudge people back through your doors—and encourage them to discover the rest of your menu along the way.
Today’s diners are frequently on their smartphones, whether browsing social media or checking out the latest restaurant reviews. Tapping into that behaviour makes total sense. A well-designed app or mobile-friendly website can be the linchpin of your loyalty scheme, offering real-time updates on reward points, delivering push notifications for limited-time offers, and streamlining redemption at the table.
Enter solutions like Sunday, which already allow customers to scan a QR code, split the bill, add a tip, and pay without the usual back-and-forth. Incorporating your loyalty programme at this moment is a no-brainer. Once the customer has settled their bill, a simple prompt can show them any rewards they’ve earned, gently encouraging them to visit again soon. This kind of immediate gratification resonates strongly with modern consumers, who love seeing instant results for their actions.
The same principle applies if you offer online takeaway or delivery. Linking your loyalty programme to the ordering platform ensures that diners earn points whether they’re feasting in your dining room or enjoying your dishes at home. Keep the experience consistent across channels, and you’ll see engagement rise—along with your bottom line.
You wouldn’t prepare an elaborate new recipe without tasting as you go, right? The same logic applies to your loyalty programme. Tracking performance metrics allows you to make adjustments before small issues become big problems.
Consider monitoring these key indicators:
Lean on your existing technology to gather these data points automatically. Many modern POS systems can integrate loyalty analytics, presenting a clear overview of who’s coming in, what they’re buying, and how frequently they return. Then, it’s up to you to interpret that information wisely—perhaps by tweaking menu items, rolling out fresh promotions, or shifting operational priorities during less busy shifts.
Your servers, hosts, and bartenders are the frontline ambassadors of your loyalty scheme. If they understand it, believe in its benefits, and communicate it with sincerity, your customers will pick up on that enthusiasm. Conversely, if your staff sees it as a chore, sign-ups and redemptions are likely to stall.
To build staff buy-in:
At its heart, your loyalty programme should feel like an extension of the genuine hospitality your staff already offers. If they can introduce it casually, answer questions confidently, and demonstrate its value, it becomes part of the meal experience rather than a corporate add-on.
One of the largest missed opportunities for many restaurants is forgetting about their most enthusiastic fans once they walk out the door. A robust loyalty programme extends beyond the final bite of dessert. Customers who experience a seamless, rewarding visit might be more than willing to share their experience online—especially if there’s a little nudge from you.
Encourage them to leave feedback on Google or share their favourite dishes on social media. Even better, provide an incentive for doing so—a small discount or bonus points if they post a photo and tag your restaurant. Many digital payment tools, such as Sunday, allow diners to leave an immediate Google review, capturing that “just had an amazing meal” emotion. That social proof can be far more persuasive to potential diners than any paid ad campaign.
Beyond that, don’t hesitate to communicate between visits. A well-timed email or push notification—perhaps highlighting your new seasonal dishes or announcing a limited-time offer—helps keep your restaurant top of mind, especially when your competitor is just down the street. But be cautious not to overwhelm people with too many messages. Quality beats quantity in most cases.
While an optimised loyalty programme can work wonders, it’s not without potential stumbling blocks. Here are a few to watch out for:
Successful restaurants don’t treat their loyalty programme like a standalone project. They weave it into the broader fabric of their brand. From social media shout-outs to in-house promotions, the message should remain consistent: “We value your continued patronage, and here’s how we show it.”
Brand identity is about more than logos or colour schemes. It’s about the story you tell through your food, your service, and your overall customer experience. By incorporating your loyalty scheme into that narrative, you emphasise the sense of community and belonging that keeps diners returning again and again. That’s particularly important in a local context, where your restaurant might serve as a neighbourhood gathering spot. Loyalty then becomes something bigger—almost like a club of regulars who help shape your brand’s reputation.
Sunday specialises in making every payment step easier for both guests and staff. Diners can scan a QR code, pay their bill, leave a tip, and even share a Google review in mere seconds. With such an intuitive platform in place, you can add loyalty tracking without creating friction. No separate sign-in process, no complicated steps—just a seamless reward system that unfolds naturally whenever a customer pays.
For the restaurant owner or manager, this centralises valuable data in one place. You can see which promotions are working, who your high-value customers are, and how often people redeem specific rewards. Armed with these insights, you can fine-tune your offering for maximum impact. Plus, the simple workflow frees your staff to focus on what really matters: delivering a memorable dining experience.
Consumer preferences shift with surprising speed. Today’s diners might be thrilled by a certain speciality dish, only to crave something else next month. Or they could become passionate about sustainability, zero-waste packaging, or plant-based cuisine. Keeping an ear to the ground helps you adjust your loyalty rewards to reflect these shifts—perhaps offering extra points for ordering eco-friendly menu items or highlighting new vegan dishes with exclusive perks.
Constantly innovating keeps your loyalty scheme fresh. If you’re unafraid to experiment, you’ll gather valuable feedback on what resonates with your audience. It could be a time-limited pop-up menu for loyalty members or a seasonal discount on new cocktails. The goal is to keep your offerings dynamic so that loyal customers always have something new to look forward to when they return.
Refining your loyalty programme isn’t a one-off job—it’s a continuous process of listening, testing, and adjusting. The good news is that with every tweak, you learn more about your diners, their habits, and their preferences. This knowledge is pure gold for shaping not just your programme, but also your menu, marketing strategy, and overall customer experience.
Consider your own favourite restaurants. Chances are, you feel a personal connection that goes beyond just a great dish or a friendly server. You appreciate the little extras—like being greeted by name, receiving exclusive perks, or getting sneak peeks at the next seasonal special. That’s where a well-executed loyalty scheme shines. It invites diners into a closer relationship with your restaurant. And once that bond is formed, it’s harder for them to look elsewhere when they’re deciding where to eat on a Friday night.
So ask yourself: Does your current loyalty scheme truly reflect what you want your guests to experience? If the answer is “not quite,” then it’s time to roll up your sleeves. Whether you’re investing in digital tools, updating the rewards on offer, or training your staff to champion the programme, each step brings you closer to building a loyal customer base.
Restaurants that deliver exceptional dining experiences, backed by thoughtful loyalty incentives, tend to stand out. And in a competitive industry, that’s precisely the advantage you need. You’re not just handing out freebies; you’re nurturing a community of diners who value what you do—and who will happily spread the word. Much like cooking a signature dish, optimising your loyalty programme is about perfecting each ingredient, from technology to staff engagement and, of course, to the rewards themselves.
By centring your efforts on genuine hospitality and practical innovation, you’ll craft a loyalty scheme that resonates with today’s diners. And that, ultimately, is the most rewarding recipe of all.
As diners become more digitally focused and more discerning than ever, a well-optimised loyalty programme can set you apart. By blending the right technology with authentic human warmth, you’ll create a dining experience that customers can’t help but rave about—online, offline, and beyond.
For more insights on evolving trends in restaurant loyalty, check out Restaurant Magazine (source) or explore McKinsey’s hospitality research (source). By staying informed and open to fresh ideas, you’ll ensure your loyalty programme remains a crowd favourite. And who knows? Your restaurant might just become the talk of the town, with eager regulars lining up for that next exclusive reward.
Drop us your details below and we’ll reach out within the next 24
See 62% of your customers join your loyalty program by integrating sunday.
