1min
Building a loyalty programme is one thing—knowing whether it’s actually working is another. In the bustling UK restaurant scene, owners often introduce loyalty cards or digital reward systems, hoping to encourage repeat visits. But if you’re not measuring results, you risk pouring time and energy into an initiative that may not deliver real returns.
The good news? With a few key metrics and simple data-collection methods, you can pinpoint how effectively your loyalty scheme is motivating guests to come back. This clarity allows you to adjust your approach—whether that’s tweaking your offers, refining your dining experience, or experimenting with fresh incentives. Think of it as tasting your dish before serving it: a quick check can ensure everything’s seasoned just right.
Before diving into analytics, it’s essential to clarify why you launched a loyalty programme in the first place. Are you aiming to increase the frequency of guest visits, boost average spend per customer, or attract new diners through word-of-mouth recommendations? Well-defined goals make it much easier to decide which metrics to track. They also help you make sense of the numbers once you start analysing them.
For example, if your primary aim is to nudge customers to order more premium dishes, you’d keep a close eye on average ticket size among loyalty members. If you’re looking to turn first-timers into regulars, your focus might centre on measuring the rate of repeat visits and tracking how quickly customers redeem loyalty perks. With clear goals in place, you can direct your time and energy toward the data points that matter most for your restaurant’s unique vision.
Not sure where to begin with data collection? Below are some of the most common loyalty programme metrics worth monitoring. Think of these as your top ingredients for evaluating whether your scheme is meeting expectations—or if it needs a pinch of salt.
Tracking these numbers on a monthly or quarterly basis can offer valuable insights into how well your loyalty strategy is performing. You don’t have to drown in data; just pick the top two or three metrics tied to your main objectives and monitor them consistently.
Restaurant owners sometimes shy away from analytics, fearing complex spreadsheets and endless hours crunching numbers. But gathering loyalty data needn’t be a headache. Start small and build from there.
For instance, many modern POS systems can automatically record whether a customer is a loyalty member, how frequently they visit, and what they typically order. If you use a QR code payment platform like sunday, you might also gather insights into tipping patterns or immediate feedback when diners settle their bill. This automated approach saves you from manual entry while delivering up-to-the-minute stats.
If you’re new to analytics, set up a simple monthly or weekly report that shows the basics. Something as concise as “Number of new loyalty sign-ups, redemption rates, and total visits by loyalty members” can already reveal a lot. As you gain comfort, you can add more data points—like average spend by time of day or feedback sentiments on your loyalty perks.
Struggling with low redemption numbers? You’re not alone. Diners often sign up for loyalty programmes with the best of intentions, only to forget about them after the meal. Here are some tactics for keeping your perks front and centre:
By tracking redemption rates and testing new approaches, you can see what resonates best with your customer base and adapt your programme accordingly.
Numbers alone can’t tell the whole story. While metrics like repeat visits or average spend can reveal patterns, direct feedback fills in the missing details. Encourage your customers to share their thoughts on your loyalty programme—whether it’s through a quick online survey, an optional prompt during digital payment, or a casual chat with regulars at their table.
This qualitative data can help you spot recurring issues or discover what diners love most. Some might say the rewards feel too small, while others may praise the convenience of a digital sign-up process. You can also glean insights on how customers perceive your brand: do they feel genuinely appreciated, or do they see the programme as just another marketing gimmick? Balancing hard data with real-world opinions leads to a more complete picture, guiding you toward improvements that resonate on a personal level.
Even the best-designed loyalty scheme comes with costs—staff training, promotional materials, free food or drink, and potential software fees. That’s why calculating ROI is crucial. In simple terms, ROI tells you how much extra revenue (or profit) your loyalty programme generates compared to what you spend on it.
To measure ROI, try this formula:
Let’s put this in more concrete terms. Suppose you’ve spent £2,000 on marketing materials, staff hours, and freebies for your loyalty scheme over the past quarter. During that time, loyalty customers brought in an additional £6,000 in revenue compared to a similar group of non-members. Subtract the £2,000 from the £6,000 to get £4,000 in net profit, then divide by £2,000. That’s an ROI of 200%—a sign your scheme is paying off. If the numbers are less impressive, it might be time to rethink your approach.
Loyalty programmes aren’t just about marketing—they also hinge on the enthusiasm of your front-of-house team. If servers or hosts don’t believe in the programme, they won’t mention it to diners, and your sign-up rates will suffer.
Consider mini incentives or friendly competitions to keep staff motivated. For instance, you could recognise employees who gather the most new loyalty sign-ups each week, or who receive the highest praise in Google Reviews. Small gestures—a complimentary meal, a gift card, or even a simple “Employee of the Month” mention—can energise your team around the initiative. Their excitement often translates into guest enthusiasm, boosting the metrics you care about most.
Like any successful recipe, a loyalty programme needs occasional adjustments. You might start with a simple points-per-pound-spent system, then realise your diners respond better to experience-based rewards like exclusive tastings or behind-the-scenes tours. Don’t be afraid to pivot if the data suggests a change is necessary.
Regularly reviewing your metrics—redemption rates, repeat visit frequency, and ROI—helps you catch warning signs early. If something’s trending downward, investigate why. Are your incentives less relevant than they used to be? Did you switch up the menu in a way that’s affecting customer satisfaction? Pinpointing the root cause allows you to adapt quickly.
Famous British chef Gordon Ramsay is known for telling restaurateurs to never get complacent—he’s right. The UK dining scene is dynamic, and tastes change rapidly. A flexible loyalty scheme that evolves with your audience is far more likely to thrive than a rigid one set up years ago and never revisited.
In many restaurants, the biggest barrier to measurement is the perceived complexity of collecting and analysing data. That’s where modern digital tools come in. An integrated payment system such as sunday can record real-time order history, table turn times, tip amounts, and immediate customer feedback. Meanwhile, loyalty software can automatically handle point accrual, redemption, and personalised offers.
By linking these platforms, you gain a seamless view of how your loyalty members behave—from the moment they sit down to when they pay and leave a review. Automated dashboards can display crucial KPIs at a glance, making it far less daunting to measure success.
Beyond your internal data, it pays to keep an eye on market-wide changes in consumer behaviour. Are diners leaning more toward eco-conscious restaurants? Are they increasingly searching for contactless or QR code-based payments? Trends like these can inform the evolution of your loyalty offers.
For further insights, resources like The Caterer (source) or MCA Insight (source) regularly publish research on UK eating habits and industry shifts. Compare your findings with broader trends to see if you’re keeping pace or whether you need to adjust your strategy.
For example, if data shows a rise in plant-based dining, consider offering special vegan rewards that might appeal to a growing segment of your customer base. By aligning your loyalty programme with what’s happening in the wider world, you stay relevant—and possibly stand out from competitors who stick to one-size-fits-all perks.
Tracking loyalty programme metrics isn’t just an exercise in number-crunching—it’s a pathway to deeper customer relationships and sustainable revenue growth. By focusing on specific goals, gathering data on the key indicators (like redemption rates and repeat visits), and harnessing digital tools to streamline the process, you can transform your loyalty scheme from a “nice idea” into a core driver of your restaurant’s success.
Don’t be afraid to test new rewards, gather direct feedback, and adjust course along the way. After all, a loyalty programme isn’t a static concept—it should evolve alongside your customers’ tastes and expectations. When you measure your progress consistently, you’re not just guessing how loyal your diners are: you have the numbers to prove it. Even better, you have the insights to make meaningful changes that keep guests coming back—hungry for more of what you do best.
Drop us your details below and we’ll reach out within the next 24
See 62% of your customers join your loyalty program by integrating sunday.
