1min
Few things are more satisfying than a bustling dining room filled with familiar faces. These are the customers who greet your team by name and praise your latest menu additions on social media. But how do you convert occasional visitors—those who pop in for a casual meal once every few months—into regulars who return week after week? A well-designed loyalty programme could be your secret ingredient.
In a competitive UK restaurant market, customer loyalty can make or break a business. According to Mintel (source), more than half of UK consumers say loyalty incentives influence their dining choices. By offering a meaningful reward system, you nudge casual diners to become repeat guests, boosting both footfall and average spend. Think of it like a signature sauce: done well, it adds depth and keeps people craving more.
Before you can transform the occasional customer into a regular, you need a clear vision of who your typical diners are and what they value. Are they young professionals looking for a quick, trendy lunch? Are they families seeking a relaxed weekend brunch spot? Perhaps you serve an older demographic who appreciate traditional dishes done right. Understanding your core audience shapes the tone of your loyalty scheme—its perks, its messaging, even the method of enrolment.
A small dose of market research can help here. You might gather data from your POS system, quick conversations with guests, or online surveys. Once you know what brings people through your doors in the first place—perhaps it’s your signature burger or your easy online reservations—you can craft a programme that encourages them to stay longer and come back sooner.
Generic reward systems often fall flat. If all you’re offering is “buy 10, get 1 free,” you may struggle to stand out, especially if half the pubs and cafés in your area have something similar. The key is designing perks that feel authentic to your restaurant’s identity and offer tangible value to your customers.
The more customised your offers, the more likely diners will feel a genuine connection. Even a small gesture can leave a lasting impression when it’s thoughtfully aligned with their tastes.
Some restaurant owners assume that the complexity of a loyalty scheme will impress customers—but confusion only discourages participation. Keep it straightforward. If diners need to fill out a lengthy form or download multiple apps, they’ll probably pass.
Instead, aim for a frictionless sign-up. A QR code at the table can be scanned in seconds, guiding guests to a simple form where they enter minimal details—perhaps just a name and an email address. If you’re using a payment solution like sunday, the sign-up can integrate seamlessly into the checkout flow, allowing diners to enrol at the moment they pay the bill. This not only boosts participation rates but also minimises the effort required from your staff.
Patience isn’t a virtue when it comes to loyalty programmes—most diners want to see quick benefits. According to a survey by Blackhawk Network (source), nearly 70% of consumers admit they’re more likely to join a scheme if they receive an immediate, tangible reward. Waiting for the tenth visit to get a freebie may discourage all but your most devoted fans.
Give occasional diners a reason to return soon. Maybe you offer a free dessert on their next visit if they join today, or double loyalty points for returning within two weeks. Clear, short-term incentives can turn a “maybe I’ll go back in a month” into “I’ll definitely be back next weekend.”
Once diners are part of your loyalty scheme, it’s time to keep them engaged. Don’t bombard them with daily emails, but a gentle nudge here and there can be effective—particularly if it feels personalised. Did your system notice that a guest usually comes in for Sunday brunch? Send them a small discount or a free drink offer tied to that time slot. Have they shown an interest in vegan specials? Let them know first about the new plant-based entrée launching next week.
Consider these promotional tactics:
By aligning these campaigns with each customer’s patterns and preferences, you gently nudge them from being an occasional diner to a frequent guest.
Your staff plays a pivotal role in turning a basic loyalty programme into something that feels personal and exciting. If servers don’t mention your scheme, or if they appear uncertain about how it works, sign-ups will lag. On the flip side, when your team genuinely believes in the value of the programme, they’ll communicate that enthusiasm to diners.
Here are a few ways to get everyone on board:
Even a minute of training can save multiple minutes of confusion at the table. Well-informed staff can also slip in subtle references to the loyalty scheme, like “Just so you know, if you join our loyalty programme today, that dessert could be on the house next time.”
If customers find payment a chore—waiting ages for the bill, splitting it awkwardly among friends—they’re less likely to leave on a high note. That’s where a QR code-based payment solution like sunday can shine. Diners simply scan the code at the table, review their bill, and tip if they wish, all within seconds. They can also be prompted to leave a Google review or join your loyalty scheme before they even stand up to go.
By streamlining the exit process, you free up staff to focus on more meaningful interactions—like discussing your new specials or inviting guests to upcoming events. Plus, integrating loyalty sign-ups into a digital payment platform means you capture that post-meal satisfaction right when diners are most receptive. A frictionless checkout can actually boost how they remember the experience, making them more open to returning soon.
No loyalty programme is set in stone. Tastes evolve, and your restaurant should evolve too. That’s why measuring key metrics—like redemption rates, frequency of return visits, or changes in average spend—is crucial. If sign-ups are healthy but redemptions are low, perhaps your rewards don’t resonate. If people join but still only visit once or twice a year, consider a shorter-term incentive to spark more frequent returns.
Data can guide these tweaks. You might learn that a £2 discount on your most popular main course works better than a free dessert no one really wants. Or you may discover that customers prefer earning points toward an overall discount instead of collecting stamps for a single free meal. Keep an eye on trends and don’t be afraid to experiment—just inform your staff of any changes so they can communicate them clearly to guests.
In a crowded marketplace, the difference between “just another loyalty programme” and a truly compelling one can boil down to the experiences you offer. Think about hosting special events for loyal customers—like a tasting menu launch, an exclusive meet-and-greet with your head chef, or a seasonal pop-up on your patio.
These experiences create stories customers love to share, both in person and online. Social media chatter around these events can attract new diners curious about what you have to offer. In essence, your loyalty scheme transcends basic discounts and starts to resemble a membership in a vibrant, ever-evolving community.
Occasional diners often remain on the fence because something about their experience didn’t fully resonate. Maybe your seating was cramped, or the menu lacked variety for their dietary needs. Whatever the barrier, feedback is your friend. Encouraging comments—through quick surveys, online reviews, or casual conversations—helps you address issues before they become deal-breakers.
Constructive criticism might highlight small details that deter repeat visits: inadequate lighting, a confusing loyalty sign-up process, or staff that seemed rushed. Positive feedback can be just as enlightening, guiding you toward strengths worth amplifying—like a creative dessert offering or the lively atmosphere on quiz nights. Listen, adapt, and communicate any updates you make so diners see you’re responsive to their needs.
What really transforms occasional patrons into faithful regulars is a feeling of belonging. They want to sense that their presence is valued. Even something as small as a “Welcome back!” or a chat about their favourite dish can spark a sense of loyalty. Loyalty programmes simply serve as a structured way to deepen that connection.
Don’t forget: People often pick their “local spot” based on more than just menu prices. The warmth of your welcome, the atmosphere you create, and the relationships you build matter immensely. Each time diners choose you over the new place down the street, it’s usually because you’ve nurtured a bond, not just offered a bargain.
Your loyalty programme isn’t a one-and-done affair. It’s an evolving component of your overall customer experience, requiring regular attention to stay fresh and relevant. That might mean rotating seasonal rewards, introducing fun challenges for members, or celebrating milestones like the programme’s anniversary with a special menu.
As you collect data and direct feedback, refine your offers and approach. If you notice a surge in popularity for plant-based dishes, for example, highlight those items in your rewards. If a certain perk isn’t generating much buzz, don’t hesitate to swap it out for something more appealing. Adaptability keeps your loyalty scheme from going stale—and your guests from seeking fresh excitement elsewhere.
According to Big Hospitality (source), restaurants that continually innovate around customer engagement tend to see stronger long-term results. So, embrace the idea that a loyalty programme should grow with your business, always reflecting your brand and serving your diners’ evolving preferences.
Ultimately, turning occasional customers into bona fide regulars starts and ends with a genuine commitment to their experience. A thoughtfully designed loyalty programme—paired with a warm team, memorable food, and an inviting atmosphere—helps forge that deeper relationship. Over time, those fleeting visits become weekly rituals, and those casual guests evolve into the brand ambassadors who sing your praises all over town. In the busy, competitive world of UK dining, that kind of loyalty is pure gold, powering not just your bottom line but also the vibrant community you build around your restaurant.
Drop us your details below and we’ll reach out within the next 24
See 62% of your customers join your loyalty program by integrating sunday.
