0min
Imagine running a bustling British restaurant on a lively Friday evening. Servers juggle trays of hearty pies, sizzling fish and chips, and freshly poured pints. As the night rolls on, a simple slip of paper is handed to each guest: their bill. Yet there’s one notable feature—an automatically generated suggested gratuity. Suddenly, you find yourself wondering: Are these friendly nudges a warm encouragement or an unwelcome demand?
Suggested gratuities have gained momentum in many parts of the world, and they are increasingly visible in the UK. So, why do some restaurateurs adopt them? And, more importantly, how do British guests really feel about seeing an automatically pre-calculated tip on the bill? The answers can guide owners like you in deciding whether or not to include these lines on your receipts—or present them on your card machines or digital payment platforms.
In this article, we will dissect the key considerations when it comes to suggested gratuities: cultural norms around tipping in the UK, new customer expectations shaped by digital habits, and the subtle balancing act between encouraging generosity and provoking annoyance. Along the way, we’ll explore real-world examples, relevant data, and best practices to help you make the right call for your restaurant.
The UK carries a distinct tipping tradition influenced by history, social norms, and practicalities. Unlike the United States, where servers often rely on tips to bolster a low hourly wage, British hospitality staff usually receive a higher base rate. According to a 2022 report from the Office for National Statistics (ONS), the average wage for accommodation and food services continues to increase year after year, though it still lags behind other sectors. This means tips remain important for servers but are not typically as vital for basic compensation as elsewhere.
British diners aren’t strangers to tips, but the norm varies. Here are some common tipping practices:
When the service is exceptional, British guests may add a bit more. Yet, while these traditions are well established, times are changing. Younger diners, in particular, embrace the convenience of digital payments. They often prefer contactless options or smartphone apps that allow them to pay quickly and leave a tip with a simple tap. In this environment, suggested gratuities have found fertile ground to take root.
On a practical level, suggested gratuities can streamline the payment process. They present diners with an immediate opportunity to add, remove, or customise a tip without fiddling with small coins or doing mental math under time pressure. If you rely on traditional card readers, you’ve likely witnessed the awkward dance: a server stands by as the customer fumbles through the tips menu, unsure of how much is appropriate. This uncertainty can lead to a lower tip or no tip at all, simply because guests feel rushed or uneasy.
Restaurants that include a suggested gratuity can benefit by:
Despite these benefits, the reality can be more nuanced. There are diners who view the addition of an automatic or pre-calculated tip as presumptuous. For some British customers, tipping is a deeply personal decision, influenced by the quality of service. An unexpected prompt to tip might feel like it’s removing their choice altogether or pressuring them to contribute more than they would have otherwise.
Here are some scenarios that can grate on a guest’s nerves:
So, does a suggested gratuity annoy or encourage? According to a 2019 YouGov poll (YouGov), around 40% of UK diners find it acceptable for a restaurant to display an optional service charge or tip suggestion, while another 30% admit it makes them uncomfortable. This divide highlights the delicate positioning of suggested gratuities: done right, they can be welcomed as a friendly nudge; done poorly, they can feel intrusive.
The key, therefore, is balance—striking the perfect note between polite suggestion and pushy demand. To achieve this, let’s explore an imaginary scenario:
Picture “The Drover’s Fork,” a fictional gastropub outside Leeds. They decided to add a suggested gratuity of 12% on every bill—but they didn’t just slap it on blindly. Instead, they:
After a month, the drover’s fork found that almost 90% of guests stuck with the suggested 12% gratuity, and fewer than 5% expressed discomfort or removed it. Positive comments centred around the staff’s transparency. Those who disliked the policy could opt out easily with no fuss. This story shows how clarity and respect for personal choice can transform an otherwise contentious feature into a genuine boost for everyone.
When integrating a suggested gratuity—whether on a printed bill or through a digital payment platform—here are some strategies you can follow to keep your guests happy:
Digital solutions, such as scannable QR codes, online ordering, and modern payment terminals, allow you to embed optional tips in an intuitive format. For instance, if you use a QR code payment app, diners can simply scan the code at their table, see various tip suggestions (like 10%, 12%, or 15%), and choose the amount that feels right. This approach spares them an awkward exchange with a hovering server and clarifies the process from start to finish.
Even better, some payments technology—like sunday—lets guests pay at their convenience, add a tip in just one click, and even share reviews on platforms such as Google. This kind of integrated system helps create a frictionless experience that encourages tipping in a natural, unforced way. Instead of feeling pressured, diners often appreciate the thoughtful prompt and opportunity to offer praise.
But remember: the user experience must remain straightforward. If your system leads to extra steps or confusion, it can undo the benefits. Always map out the payment flow from the guest’s perspective. Is it clear? Do they understand that the suggested tip is optional? Are they given a chance to provide feedback without feeling harassed? These are crucial questions to ask.
When you introduce a suggested gratuity, it’s important to consider how staff will share in that extra revenue and how diners will perceive its allocation. The government has taken an interest in ensuring tips go directly to employees. In fact, the Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy once announced measures aimed at preventing businesses from skimming tips that were meant for workers.
Therefore, you’ll want to:
Transparency around these details not only reassures diners but also fosters a sense of fairness within your team. Everyone, from the chefs to the front-of-house staff, should feel that suggested gratuities are improving their livelihoods in a legitimate way.
Your staff are your brand ambassadors. If they feel awkward about how tips are suggested or distributed, it will show in their interactions with customers. Ensure that they know:
Encourage them to remain polite and understanding if guests have issues. Empower them with real-world scripts or guidelines. For instance, train staff to say something like: “Our system sometimes adds a 12% gratuity, but it’s totally up to you—if you’d rather leave a different tip or no tip at all, I can remove it straight away. We just want you to have a lovely experience.” Armed with a helpful, friendly approach, your team can turn potential friction into a positive moment of connection and trust with diners.
Choosing the right percentage is a common concern. Restaurant owners may wonder: “Is 10% too low? Will 20% scare people off?” It depends largely on your establishment, its location, and your clientele.
In many UK cities, 10% to 12.5% is typical if an automatic service charge isn’t already being used. High-end restaurants sometimes push it to 15%, but they usually make it very clear that diners are free to opt out. Some bistros and gastro-pubs may keep it slightly lower to cater to more price-sensitive crowds.
Ultimately, your goal is to pick a level that reflects the standard of your service but doesn’t needlessly upset guests. You can even test different percentages to see if one yields more positive feedback, returning customers, or fewer tip removals. Just be sure to monitor diner sentiment; unsolicited complaints on social media or direct remarks that the suggested tip feels excessive should prompt a rethink.
While the UK as a whole has certain tipping customs in common, it’s worth acknowledging that practices can vary. Big cities like London, Manchester, and Edinburgh tend to see more frequent tipping—often overshadowed by the ever-present service charge. Meanwhile, rural pubs may still rely on old-fashioned tip jars at the bar, where patrons toss in spare change.
If your establishment is in a smaller town or a more traditional part of the country, consider how local culture might perceive suggested gratuities. If people typically leave smaller tokens of appreciation, an 18% suggestion might appear outlandish. Tailor your approach to local realities to avoid alienating loyal customers who might not be used to big tips.
Let’s check back in with “The Drover’s Fork,” our imaginary gastropub. Six months after introducing their 12% suggested gratuity, they noticed a tiny uptick in feedback describing the suggestion as “a bit cheeky.” Rather than ignoring it, management listened. They polled a sampling of local patrons and found that while most were comfortable with the 12%, a small but vocal portion felt it was slightly too high for what they considered a casual dining environment.
As a result, The Drover’s Fork revised their printed policies and lowered the suggested gratuity to 10%. They put up a friendly notice at the host stand, reading: “We politely suggest a 10% gratuity, but please let us know if you’d rather adjust or remove it. Thank you for supporting our team!” The complaints dropped, staff were still earning good tips, and the conversation around tipping became more positive.
That scenario highlights an essential mantra: stay agile. Listen to your customers, test out small changes, and adjust when the data suggests it’s time.
Beyond tipping, modern guests often enjoy leaving quick feedback on review platforms. This helps them share their experience and gives you valuable insights. If your payment system seamlessly integrates a step that says, “Would you like to add a gratuity and leave a quick online review?” it can be a powerful marketing tool—provided it remains polite and optional.
An organic request for feedback aligns with a tip suggestion in many guests’ minds: they both represent a chance to say “thank you” for a job well done. Provided your servers deliver consistent quality and warmth, both tips and positive reviews should follow naturally.
When diners have a negative or neutral experience, they’re likely to skip the tip or leave a lower one. That’s their prerogative. At the same time, if you’re collecting these data points through digital channels, you can gather constructive criticism to refine your service.
Restaurants that embrace digital payment solutions like sunday’s QR-code system give customers a swift, transparent way to settle up. Crucially, this approach can incorporate suggested gratuities in a manner that feels modern and seamless. The advantage? Younger patrons, quick-lunch professionals, and internationally minded guests often prefer scanning a code to queueing by a physical card machine or fishing out cash.
By revealing optional tip suggestions on the user’s own phone screen, you can gently prompt generosity without forcing it. It’s a subtle invitation—rather like offering someone a top-up of their coffee instead of pushing them to buy another cup. In the end, diners appreciate having the power to choose.
If you’re preparing to introduce or refine a suggested gratuity approach in your restaurant, communication is everything. You can:
Above all, never trap or guilt-trip your customers into tipping. Making them feel cornered is a surefire recipe for resentment. On the other hand, an open and educational approach fosters goodwill.
Not if you manage it well. The key is transparency. Make it clear that the tip is optional and adjustable. Most regulars will understand, especially if they already love your establishment. You can even mention privately to loyal guests that they can remove or change the tip if they prefer something else.
Lowering your set rate might mean a slightly smaller margin on each tip. However, if it helps your diners feel more at ease, you may end up with fewer tip removals and more visits overall, which can translate into consistent or even higher total earnings for staff over time. Balancing what feels fair to both customers and employees tends to generate the best results.
An automatic service charge is an alternative, but it often carries a more mandatory tone and can irritate patrons who feel forced to pay. A suggested gratuity, labelled as discretionary, allows for more flexibly. It respects British diners’ preference for free choice while still guiding them toward a tip.
Make a firm policy on how tips and service charges are allocated. Some restaurants pool gratuities and split them between front-of-house and back-of-house. Others allow servers to keep tips individually. Whatever you opt for, communicate it internally so everyone knows the system—and mention it to customers if they ask.
In tourist-heavy areas, you might have diners from tipping-intensive countries such as the US or Canada. They may be more accustomed to leaving a bigger tip. You can still use a suggested gratuity, but consider whether an 18-20% prompt might work in that context. Alternatively, keep it around 12% but add a note clarifying that, given cultural differences, guests are welcome to raise or lower it as they see fit.
Suggested gratuities can be a powerful strategy for driving more income for your team while still respecting your diners’ sense of autonomy. By striking a balance—transparent communication, genuinely optional tips, and technology that simplifies the process—you can remain inviting to British guests and international visitors alike. Above all, remember that tips come from a place of gratitude and goodwill. When you give people a fair chance to express that gratitude on their own terms, you set the table for a satisfying experience all around.
