1min
Picture this: you’ve invested in quality ingredients, trained your staff to perfection, crafted a memorable décor, and fine-tuned each dish on your menu. The doors swing open, customers walk in, enjoy a meal, then leave satisfied. But does the story end there? Not in the digital age. Today, those same patrons often go straight to Google Reviews. Their impressions might be what leads another diner to book a table or choose a competitor. In the UK, more than 95% of prospective customers turn to online reviews before making a decision, and restaurants are at the top of that list.
In French, you might say, “Comment les avis Google façonnent la réputation en ligne d’un restaurant,” but the concept remains global: Google Reviews are a major factor in shaping your online reputation. They can propel you to the top of local search results, attract new diners, and even influence the press to notice your establishment. Looking after them isn’t optional; it’s a must.
In simple terms, Google Reviews are customer testimonials posted on a restaurant’s Google Business Profile. If a diner searches your restaurant’s name on Google, they’ll likely spot a star rating out of five, alongside individual reviews. These ratings and comments appear wherever Google surfaces your local listing: from Google Maps results to the “Local Pack” in search results.
Why does this matter so much? Because every potential diner sees this star average (and the number of reviews) before even stepping foot in your restaurant. It’s not just word-of-mouth at your local pub anymore; it’s word-of-google, open 24/7 for the world to see.
Ever wondered why some restaurants in your neighbourhood rank higher than others, even if they’re tucked away on a side street? Google’s local search algorithm weighs several factors, and the quantity and quality of reviews is one of them. A restaurant with a healthy stream of positive, detailed, and recent reviews is more likely to appear higher in local search results, especially in the restaurant category.
An extensive survey by BrightLocal indicates that 77% of consumers “always” or “regularly” read reviews for local businesses. In other words, if you’re not managing your Google Reviews, you may be missing out on a steady flow of organic traffic from search engines. Search visibility means more diners discovering your establishment—and, ultimately, more booked tables.
Let’s talk about the star rating system. Have you noticed how a simple star rating influences your sense of trust? Research shows that people are significantly more likely to pick a restaurant with a 4.2+ rating than one with a 3.8 rating—even if the latter has more reviews. There’s something about a 4+ star rating that just feels safer.
For UK diners, it’s not just about scoring “intuition points.” Many will filter by rating on Google Maps when searching for a place to eat. If you’re lower than the competition, you risk being excluded simply because of a numeric filter. In the eyes of potential guests, higher star ratings translate to better perceived quality. The difference between 4.0 and 4.5 stars might sound minor, but in the hospitality world, it can mean a significant difference in foot traffic.
Trust isn’t just built by having any old cluster of reviews. Customers crave authenticity and consistency. A sudden spike of overly generic five-star ratings might raise eyebrows. Instead, guests look for detailed accounts:
When potential diners see real stories that resonate with them, they’re far more likely to choose you over a competitor. And once they do visit, they already have a level of trust anchored in testimonies from your past customers.
Reviews are not just there for show. Sometimes a customer praises your homemade bread; other times, they highlight an issue with slow service at lunch hours. Either way, each review is valuable feedback. Here are a few practical ways to integrate them into your operational strategy:
By showing how seriously you take feedback, you build a sense of community around your restaurant. Diligently acting on mistakes and highlighting successes fosters loyalty among regulars, letting them feel part of your journey.
Let’s face it—nobody opens a café or brasserie hoping for bad press. At some point, though, a diner may leave a scathing review: “My soup was cold,” “The staff was rude,” or “I found the dish overpriced.” While it stings, it’s also an opportunity to show how responsive and caring you are.
Here’s how to handle negativity with grace:
Interestingly, a fair resolution of a negative review can even win back disgruntled customers—and show prospective diners that your management is attentive. In many cases, the reviewer might update their review positively after a warm response and resolution.
You might be wondering, “How do I get more of these positive Google Reviews?” Truthfully, you can’t force customers to write glowing praise, but you can create an environment that naturally encourages them to share five-star feedback:
While you don’t want to be too pushy, small reminders can significantly boost the volume of your positive reviews—especially when your overall experience deserves those high ratings.
Let’s illustrate the power of Google Reviews with a (fictional) example. Imagine a local pizzeria, “Bella Napoli,” operating in a suburban corner of Manchester. Despite having excellent authentic Neapolitan pizzas, they suffered from old reviews relating to chaotic opening days and slow service. Their average rating hovered around 3.4 stars, and footfall remained modest.
The new manager initiated a service reboot: better staff training, improved scheduling, and a new approach to ingredient sourcing. He then encouraged his team to politely ask happy customers to leave feedback on Google. He also responded publicly and graciously to older negative reviews, detailing the changes the restaurant had made.
Within three months, Bella Napoli’s Google rating climbed to 4.2 stars, and they were receiving triple the number of positive reviews per month. The pizzeria also noticed a surge in online orders and table reservations. By focusing on operational improvements, then harnessing Google Reviews to get the word out, Bella Napoli effectively changed its online reputation—and drew in more customers.
Crafting well-thought-out responses to reviews can set you apart from the restaurant next door that never replies. Whether the feedback is lavish with praise or tinged with disappointment, consider these tips:
When you take the time to reply to reviews—good or bad—prospective customers see a restaurant that cares about its guests and consistently strives to improve.
Online reviews tend to have a snowball effect: the more positive reviews you get, the more trust you build, and the more people who come in to test you out. Satisfied customers who see others’ feedback are emboldened to leave their own endorsements.
In a sense, Google Reviews act as a stage where each customer becomes a mini-critic. Because the platform is so immediate, they can post a photo of last night’s special or mention the impeccable service they received. Over time, these visible testaments become a magnet for diners seeking reliability in their restaurant choices.
Here’s how you can amplify that social proof:
When we talk about online reputation, we’re talking about more than just a star rating. For a restaurant owner, tracking the nuances in reviews can help you pinpoint small issues before they become big problems.
How can you do this effectively?
This data can then be compared against your internal metrics (daily foot traffic, average table spend, etc.) to see exactly how online perceptions are influencing your on-the-ground results.
Before focusing on attracting reviews, make sure you’ve fully claimed and optimised your Google Business Profile. That means:
A polished listing signals professionalism and encourages happy customers to leave positive reviews. If your profile is neglected or missing basic information, you might be missing out on potential diners who just want to double-check your closing time before deciding to visit.
We’ve touched on how face-to-face contact is the best place to encourage a review. But how do you get them to pull out their phone right then and there? Innovative digital tools simplify that process. For instance:
In an age where “frictionless” experiences are highly valued, blending your final step of service (payment) with a gentle request for feedback can become a game-changer for your online rating.
Some restaurants try to hide negative reviews. Not only is it nearly impossible to control what’s posted on Google, but it’s also misguided. Transparency fosters trust. Diners accept that not everything is always perfect. In fact, too many suspiciously flawless five-star reviews might come across as inauthentic.
Striking a balance:
Allowing customers to see a range of feedback demonstrates you have nothing to hide. This honest display often builds credibility more than a pristine (but suspicious) page of exclusively five-star ratings.
Restaurants frequently run private parties, holiday specials, or unique tasting menus. Did you know Google Reviews can also help amplify these events? When diners comment on how much they loved your Christmas set menu or your wine-tasting event, prospective guests browsing your reviews during those seasons might feel instantly drawn in.
What you can do:
Your restaurant’s marketing efforts likely encompass social media, email campaigns, local print ads, or even TV spots. Don’t forget to integrate your Google Reviews into that mix. Potential customers often cross-reference multiple sources before choosing where to eat. When they see a business consistently praised across Google, Instagram, and local news articles, it cements your position as a local favourite.
Consider:
Unfortunately, not every negative review is genuine. Sometimes a competitor—or a personal grudge—can lead to ‘fake’ postings. If you suspect that your restaurant has been targeted by an unfair or malicious review, here’s how to address it:
Most important is not to get dragged into an online feud. Conduct yourself with composure and rely on the authenticity of your genuine diners to uphold your reputation.
There’s no fixed number, but having at least a threshold of 10 or more reviews helps your average rating appear more credible. Beyond that, consistency matters. Aim for a steady stream of fresh reviews rather than a big batch all at once.
Absolutely. In most cases, politely inviting happy customers to leave feedback is encouraged. Just ensure you’re not offering bribes or incentives for positive reviews, as this violates Google’s guidelines and could damage credibility.
Claiming and verifying your Google Business Profile is free and quite straightforward. Go to Google Business to set it up. Ensure your address, phone number, and opening hours are correct, then add quality photos. Once done, share your listing with regulars and new customers to collect your first reviews.
While you don’t have to respond to every single comment, replying to as many as possible shows you’re engaged with your diners. Even a concise “Thank you for your feedback!” can make someone feel seen and appreciated.
A platform like sunday enables guests to pay quickly with their phones. Once payment is done, you can provide a direct link to your Google review page. It reduces friction and allows diners to share feedback while the experience is fresh in their minds.
Cultivating positive Google Reviews is a continuous process. It involves serving great food, providing memorable experiences, and then nudging your guests to share those experiences publicly. By offering top-notch hospitality and strategically prompting feedback—especially when everything is still piping hot in their memory—you can steadily boost your online reputation.
Wherever your restaurant is located in the UK, one thing remains constant: diners look for trust above all else, and Google Reviews serve as a key indicator of that trust. Whether you’re planning an expansion, launching a new seasonal menu, or simply wanting to fill more tables on weeknights, a strong online presence can give you that extra push.
In an era where ‘reputation is everything,’ Google Reviews have evolved from a nice-to-have to an absolute necessity for success. Now is the time to harness their power, fine-tune your approach, and turn satisfied customers into brilliant ambassadors—one star at a time.
Drop us your details below and we’ll reach out within the next 24
Say goodbye to bad ratings and hello to 5*s. Get to know your customers with our integrated rating & review feature, which allows you to get more reviews, better ratings and more visibility online.
